28.18 FAILURE TO OBEY THE LAWFUL ORDER OF A [POLICE] [FIRE] [TRAFFIC] OFFICIAL
Official jury instruction text reproduced for information. It is not legal advice; the instruction given in a case depends on the facts and the court.
Failure to Obey a Police Officer Charges in Miami-Dade
Failure to Obey the Lawful Order of a Police, Fire, or Traffic Official | Florida Standard Jury Instruction (Criminal) 28.18 | § 316.072(3), Fla. Stat.
This charge says a person willfully failed or refused to follow a lawful order or direction from a law enforcement officer, a traffic crash investigation officer, a traffic infraction enforcement officer, or a member of the fire department at the scene of a fire, rescue operation, or other emergency. Under subsection (3), it is a second-degree misdemeanor. The word willfully matters. A mistake or a missed signal is different from a refusal.
What the State Must Prove
The State carries the whole burden. To convict, it must prove every element below beyond a reasonable doubt. These words are from the official instruction the judge reads to the jury (Florida Standard Jury Instructions in Criminal Cases, 28.18). Words in brackets and parentheses are choices the judge fills in for the actual case.
To prove the crime of Failure to Obey the Lawful Order of a (insert type of official from the list in § 316.072(3), Fla. Stat.), the State must prove the following five elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
(Defendant) was [operating a [vehicle] [bicycle]] [walking] upon [a state-maintained highway] [county-maintained highway] [municipal street or alley] [place where vehicles have the right to travel].
(Name of official) gave a lawful [order] [or] [direction] to (defendant) regarding the operation of a vehicle or bicycle or the movement of a pedestrian.
At the time, (name of official) was acting in [his] [her] capacity as a [law enforcement officer] [traffic crash investigation officer] [traffic infraction enforcement officer] [member of the fire department who was at the scene of a fire, rescue operation, or other emergency].
(Defendant) knew that [he] [she] had been given a[n] [order] [direction] by a [law enforcement officer] [traffic crash investigation officer] [traffic infraction enforcement officer] [member of the fire department who was at the scene of a fire, rescue operation, or other emergency].
(Defendant) willfully failed to obey [or] [willfully refused to comply] with the [order] [or] [direction] given.
Read the official text and the full instruction on our Elements of the Crime page.
What That Means in Plain English
- The State must prove you were on a covered road or place, as a driver, cyclist, or pedestrian.
- It must prove the official gave you a lawful order or direction about driving, or about a pedestrian's movement.
- It must prove the official was acting in that official capacity.
- It must prove you knew you had been given the order or direction.
- It must prove you willfully failed to obey or refused to comply.
Common Defenses
Every case is different. Here are some of the areas a defense lawyer may look at.
- Lawful order. A lawyer may ask whether the order was lawful and tied to traffic or pedestrian movement.
- Knowledge. A lawyer may ask whether you heard or saw the order and understood it.
- Willful. A lawyer may ask whether you refused, or whether you were confused, blocked, or had no safe way to comply.
- Official capacity. A lawyer may ask whether the person was acting in one of the listed roles at that time.
- Place. A lawyer may ask whether the location was a place the statute covers.
How a Defense Lawyer Looks for Reasonable Doubt
The State has to prove each element. A lawyer may test each one.
- Collect bodycam, dash camera, and nearby business video.
- Get dispatch records and the officer's notes to fix the timing and the exact words used.
- Visit the scene and photograph signs, lights, lanes, and sight lines.
- Interview witnesses and compare their accounts to the report.
What to Do Right Now
- Do not discuss the case with the police or on social media before you speak to a lawyer.
- Write down what happened while you remember it, and keep your papers, texts, and photos.
- Do not contact the other person if a judge told you not to.
- Call us early. Deadlines in criminal cases move fast.
Talk to a Lawyer
Charged, or think you may be? Call (305) 209-0384 for a free consultation. We answer 24/7. Se habla español.
This page is general information, not legal advice, and it does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no result is promised.
Source: The Florida Bar, edition of October 9, 2026. Always check the official site for the latest version. Backup copy (PDF)
- Instruction
- 28.18
- Statute
- § 316.072(3), Fla. Stat.
- Edition
- Florida Standard Jury Instructions in Criminal Cases, complete set published by The Florida Bar, updated October 9, 2026
- Official source
- The Florida Bar: criminal jury instructions
Elements
Quoted word for word from the official text. Florida Standard Jury Instructions in Criminal Cases, complete set published by The Florida Bar, updated October 9, 2026.
To prove the crime of Failure to Obey the Lawful Order of a (insert type of official from the list in § 316.072(3), Fla. Stat.), the State must prove the following five elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
1. (Defendant) was [operating a [vehicle] [bicycle]] [walking] upon [a state-maintained highway] [county-maintained highway] [municipal street or alley] [place where vehicles have the right to travel].
2. (Name of official) gave a lawful [order] [or] [direction] to (defendant) regarding the operation of a vehicle or bicycle or the movement of a pedestrian.
3. At the time, (name of official) was acting in [his] [her] capacity as a [law enforcement officer] [traffic crash investigation officer] [traffic infraction enforcement officer] [member of the fire department who was at the scene of a fire, rescue operation, or other emergency].
4. (Defendant) knew that [he] [she] had been given a[n] [order] [direction] by a [law enforcement officer] [traffic crash investigation officer] [traffic infraction enforcement officer] [member of the fire department who was at the scene of a fire, rescue operation, or other emergency].
5. (Defendant) willfully failed to obey [or] [willfully refused to comply] with the [order] [or] [direction] given.
Lesser-included offenses
As the instruction lists them, word for word.
FAILURE TO OBEY LAWFUL ORDER— 316.072(3)
| CATEGORY ONE | CATEGORY TWO | FLA. STAT. | INS. NO. |
|---|---|---|---|
| None | |||
| Attempt | 777.04(1) | 5.1 |
Related practice page
Other Criminal Traffic Charges in Miami
Official source: The Florida Bar: criminal jury instructions
Official jury instruction text reproduced for information. It is not legal advice; the instruction given in a case depends on the facts and the court.